74: End Days for TikTok in North America?
Narrative Control as National Security Part 1
There is an unmistakable tension on TikTok. Scroll through the app, and you'll sense it in the posts, the comment sections, even the choice of music—users bracing themselves for the worst.
The Supreme Court hearings earlier this week did little to inspire hope. Justices appeared skeptical of TikTok’s arguments that banning the app violates the First Amendment, and the government’s framing of TikTok as a national security threat carried the day in court. The case, brought against the backdrop of rising geopolitical tension, seems poised to deliver a devastating blow to TikTok’s presence in the United States. By January 19, ByteDance must either divest TikTok or see the app banned outright.
But what’s happening in the courts is only half the story. To understand the full scope of TikTok’s potential demise, we need to look at the cultural undercurrents—both online and offline—that have shaped this moment. It’s not just about security concerns; it’s about narrative control, cultural dominance, and the ability of platforms to empower grassroots storytelling. That and cute doggies!
Tiktok failed to load.Enable 3rd party cookies or use another browser
The Supreme Court’s Leanings
During oral arguments, the justices engaged with TikTok’s claims that the federal law targeting ByteDance singles it out unfairly, violating constitutional protections. Yet the tone was clear: when national security is at stake, constitutional rights can and often do take a back seat. Justice Sotomayor’s questioning highlighted the unprecedented scope of the law but also acknowledged the potential risks of allowing foreign-controlled platforms to dominate U.S. digital spaces.
The Biden administration’s arguments were equally revealing. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar argued that the app poses a unique threat, with ByteDance’s ownership making it vulnerable to influence from the Chinese government. But for many observers, the hearings illuminated a deeper agenda: TikTok’s very structure—its capacity to amplify bottom-up narratives—is what truly makes it dangerous in the eyes of U.S. elites.
Narrative Control as National Security
The United States has long relied on its cultural dominance to project power abroad and unify its citizenry at home. TikTok disrupts that dynamic. Its algorithm, driven by user creativity and spontaneity, undermines the curated narratives of traditional media. On TikTok, narratives about climate change, inequality, and police brutality spread rapidly, often challenging official accounts and mainstream framing.
Tiktok failed to load.Enable 3rd party cookies or use another browser
This is a moment of reckoning for the U.S. cultural industrial complex. As Hollywood’s traditional machinery falters under strikes, and declining revenues, TikTok’s model shows how fractured—and potentially liberating—the media landscape has become. This, perhaps more than any alleged data security issue, explains the government’s urgency in dismantling TikTok’s presence.
The Fires of Los Angeles
Yet as the legal battle unfolds, a parallel catastrophe is playing out on the West Coast. Los Angeles is ablaze—literally. Massive wildfires have engulfed parts of the city, throwing its cultural heart into chaos. Hollywood, already grappling with strikes and declining influence, is further destabilized. It’s almost too symbolic: the epicenter of American narrative-making is on fire, just as the platform most capable of subverting those narratives faces its own existential threat.
Tiktok failed to load.Enable 3rd party cookies or use another browser
This is not just a coincidence. TikTok, with its 170 million U.S. users, represents a fundamental challenge to the U.S. cultural industrial complex. While Hollywood’s stories are exported to the world, TikTok’s decentralized model allows U.S. citizens to craft their own narratives, often in direct opposition to the polished, controlled messaging of mainstream media. From grassroots organizing to viral trends, TikTok has become a platform where power flows from the bottom up—a deeply destabilizing force for the status quo.
Foreshadowing the Future
This TikTok chill isn’t confined to the United States. The Canadian government is also moving to push TikTok out of the country from an operational perspective, laying the groundwork for a potential app ban similar to what is unfolding south of the border. Framing its actions around national security and data privacy, Canada’s approach underscores the growing international alignment on restricting TikTok’s influence. For Canadian users, the sense of loss mirrors the anxiety felt in the U.S., as a key platform for self-expression and grassroots storytelling comes under threat.
These last days of TikTok feel less like an ending and more like a beginning—or at least, a warning. The app’s struggle against censorship and control mirrors broader struggles playing out across the United States. As Trump prepares to return to the White House, his inauguration looms as another symbol of consolidation, control, and the narrowing of narratives.
For TikTok users, the impending ban feels personal. This isn’t just about losing an app; it’s about losing a space where voices—especially marginalized ones—can rise and resonate. The sense of mourning on the platform is palpable, but so too is the defiance. Videos tagged #SaveTikTok are trending, as creators document what may be their final days on the app.
Coming Next: The Court’s Decision
In part two, we’ll examine the Supreme Court’s final ruling and what it means for the future of TikTok, digital platforms, and authority in the U.S. Whether the app survives or not, its fate offers critical lessons about power, narrative, and the shifting dynamics of control in the 21st century.
For now, as TikTok’s sun sets, we’re left to wonder: what will rise in its place?
Tiktok failed to load.Enable 3rd party cookies or use another browser